119: The Power Of Great Performance Conversations, With Joe Hirsch

Dr. Pelè: 00:01
Welcome to the Profitable Happiness Podcast, where we interview highly successful workplace wellness executives, experts, and entrepreneurs and learn how they have found success where happiness meets business profitability. Hello everyone, this is Dr. Pelè with the Profitable Happiness Podcast, and it is my special, special honor and pleasure to introduce you to Joe Hirsch. Now Joe Hirsch is a bestselling author of the book The Feedback Fix, and he’s a speaker and he’s a well-known leader of the Semeka Partners. Now the thing about you, Joe, that I want to tell the world that maybe, you know, people may not know besides your, your success, is that you are probably one of the world’s premier advocates for Marshall Goldsmith’s well-known methodology. And for anybody who doesn’t know Marshall Goldsmith, he is at the top of the food chain for executive coaches. And I’ve been a follower, a fan of Marshall all my life. So when I heard about you, I was like, I got to talk to him because you are the authority on feedback and your book, The Feedforward Fix. Or the feedback fix rather, feedforward, is something I want to learn so much about. So having said all that, Joe, can you just tell us how you became at the forefront of the feedback revolution, if you will?

Joe Hirsch: 01:33
Hey, Dr. Pelè, great to be talking with you and your audience today. And I appreciate the kind words, but I would, I would immediately push back and say that I’m just part of a movement of people who are trying to help make these performance conversations happier and more profitable for everyone involved. But I think for me, the, the moment of revelation came very early on in my career. I come from an education background. I’ve taught students really at various levels— primary, secondary, even adults now in the work that I do. And even though educators give a lot of feedback, they don’t necessarily take it very well. And I, and I was one of those. Mm-hmm. Initially, I was very certain that my way of doing things was correct, and I wasn’t really interested in hearing feedback from other people. And it wasn’t until I began to realize that, that there was a disconnect between the way I saw myself and the way that others were seeing me, and that this vision of who I was was not at all aligned with the vision that others had created about me. And that led to some very painful moments professionally and even personally. And as a result of trying to improve my own abilities in receiving feedback and giving it with, with greater heart and greater sense, I began to realize that there is a better way, a way that’s rooted in research and that is accessible to everybody. And that led me to Marshall Goldsmith’s Feedforward approach, which is really a tool for generating very quick conversations about performance or about goals that you have that Marshall uses in some of his seminars, and that I realized had a real science underpinning to it. So with Marshall’s blessing and support, I began to uncover the underpinnings of Feedforward, the behavioral and psychological bodies of research that help people have these conversations in a way that leads to greater joy, not fear. And it’s something that animates all the work that I do today.

Dr. Pelè: 03:46
Wow. Wow. And you know what, what a story. I think I shared with you earlier that what I admire the most about your story is that you’re not just a guy who went and read a book and decided to write your own. You’ve struggled and lived through this. You know, you’re, you know, there’s a saying, a leader is one who knows the way, goes the way, and shows the way. You are the hero of the story in the sense that you’ve felt the pain. You know, I would love to, well, first of all, I want to give you a chance to teach us about the feedback fix. We’ll get to that.

Joe Hirsch: 04:17
But

Dr. Pelè: 04:17
before we do that, you know, I think it’s well known that interpersonal dynamics are at the center of any kind of success in business, period. And you know, if you don’t know, as you said, if you don’t know what people think of you, I mean, it’s like walking down the road blindfolded, right?

Joe Hirsch: 04:33
Yeah.

Dr. Pelè: 04:34
It’s like you’ve got this huge blind spot. You only know what you think you know, but the whole world is responding to you a different way. Can you just tell us a little bit about the challenges, just the basic concept behind needing to see what people think of you and not just what you think of yourself? I mean, what, where is that from? Why is that relevant to all of psychology and to what we do every day today?

Joe Hirsch: 04:58
Studies show that we are painfully, painfully unaware of how we show up to other people. So one very chilling statistic is that 90% of the people have only 10% self-awareness.

Dr. Pelè: 05:15
Wow.

Joe Hirsch: 05:15
Which is a vast, vast gap between what we know about ourselves and, and what others know about us or think about us. Since you talked about Marshall, Marshall Goldsmith likes to say that we’re professionals in what we do, But we’re amateurs in who we want to become.

Dr. Pelè: 05:32
Wow.

Joe Hirsch: 05:32
And it’s so true because the way that we think about ourselves is often misaligned with the way that others think about us. And this comes to a head in performance conversations because too often when 2 people are talking about one person’s performance, the giver and the receiver, the view of the giver is not at all aligned with the receiver. And there’s lots of reasons for that. It runs really deep on a neuropsychological level.

Dr. Pelè: 06:04
Mm-hmm.

Joe Hirsch: 06:05
And part of the challenge of giving effective feedback is coming to terms with these barriers that create a fail in so many of these performance conversations. Before you get a feedback fix, you’ve got to address the fail. And for many, many people, coming to terms with what makes feedback so challenging is the greatest challenge of all, having to confront very natural ingrained habits and views about these conversations, about dynamics and the interplay of performance and potential, and trying to help people cut away through some of that noise and really have a clear understanding of what’s happening. That’s a real difficult thing for people to do.

Dr. Pelè: 06:54
Yeah. Yeah. You know, you know, when I was in the employee ranks, I remember one of the scariest things was that feedback conversation that you’re talking about. Give us a sense of why it’s important for leaders to have these conversations with, with team members or followers. How does that play into the overall success of an organization? Where, I mean, performance reviews, like, like everybody talks about not liking them, I think. Um, but they’re a necessary thing. How does all that string together to, to create the success people, companies are seeking?

Joe Hirsch: 07:31
Well, you can’t fix what you don’t know. And too often people are unaware of their shortcomings. That certainly was my case. And I was, I was not, clear on where I was coming up short.

Dr. Pelè: 07:48
Hmm.

Joe Hirsch: 07:49
And, and without that understanding, without that information and that awareness, I wasn’t able to contribute the best of myself to the betterment of my organization. And the, the reason why this matters to every organization, to every team, is because without a clear understanding of where people stand, they can’t contribute the best of themselves. So it is the job of every leader and really the job of every organization to create the conditions that allow for clarity and compassion when describing the work that people do. Clarity because we need to know where we stand and compassion because we need to do it in a way that isn’t soul-crushing. And that actually helps people see themselves as more, not less, than they were when they went into that conversation.

Dr. Pelè: 08:45
You know, Joe, where were you when I was struggling as an employee back in the day? Because I needed to hear this.

Joe Hirsch: 08:52
I was probably struggling right alongside you.

Dr. Pelè: 08:55
You were struggling as well. You know, and I’ll tell you why, because, you know, in my, you know, in my experience, I’ve had these leadership-follower or employee conversations. And they never turned out right because my leader would tell me things like, Pelè— back then I wasn’t Dr. Pelè— Pelè, you talk too much in meetings. You’re always giving us your opinion. You know, don’t you realize that, you know, it’s like, what if they could have, as you said, compassion? What if someone could have said, you know what, maybe this isn’t the right role for you because you’re such a, a powerful communicator? How about that? You know, maybe you should go and be an evangelist for our product as opposed to sitting in this office trying to get your opinion heard. I just feel like I got all the wrong info. But, you know, maybe someone out there is listening, realizing that this is a challenge for them. Help put us in the frame of mind of the problem that people in employee situations, team situations are facing. You know, what is that? What is the challenge they face? And then let’s use that to lead into The Feedback Fix. I’d love to hear how you wrote a book about that, but what was the problem you were trying to solve with that book?

Joe Hirsch: 10:08
Well, I wanted to give people a clear understanding of how to hold more authentic conversations about work that didn’t reduce people to less than what they could become. And drawing on the science and applying these strategies, I, wanted to create a framework that would allow everyday conversations to create greater agency for individuals, to foster more accountability, and yet have greater authenticity. And all the while really operating on a very simple premise, but a very powerful premise, and that is that feedback doesn’t have to be a source of fear, but can be a source of joy. And if we change the dynamics and the focus of those conversations from power to partnership and from past to future,

Dr. Pelè: 11:13
ooh,

Joe Hirsch: 11:14
then we are creating the conditions that allow for those conversations to take place, for individuals to communicate with greater clarity, With greater authenticity and with greater compassion and agency for the person who’s receiving it.

Dr. Pelè: 11:30
Okay. So you’ve just caused a problem now because you got to explain to me what you mean by the shift from power to partnership and how a shift from past to future makes a difference in these leader-to-follower, you know, inner dynamics that creates ultimate profitability. I know it’s a lot, but Can you break this down for us in terms of examples?

Joe Hirsch: 11:53
Yeah, let’s, well, let’s start with the orientation of most feedback conversations. So typically most feedback occurs well after the event has passed. So you may be getting feedback at the end of a project, at the end of a quarter, maybe even only once a year. And the feedback that you’re receiving most often describes events that you can no longer change or control. It operates in the immutable past.

Dr. Pelè: 12:19
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 12:20
And there’s a problem with that. The biggest problem of all, aside from the fact that it’s no longer changeable, is that it actually is subject to greater bias and greater emotional fragility. Let me break that down for you and your listeners. The bias is because when I’m describing events that occurred long ago, I’m subject to greater forgetfulness. Research shows that we forget up to 90% of what we’ve learned within a course of 7 days. Usually there’s a very steep drop-off within the first 24 hours. So you learn something new, you go to a conference, you, you experience something, you gain new information, and then that is very sharp and sudden receding of that information, of memory loss within 24 hours. That curve steepens over the course of the next 6 days so that by the time a week has passed, you forget almost 90% of what’s happened.

Dr. Pelè: 13:19
Yeah, yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 13:19
The forgetting curve. Now, if you apply that to a business context and you’re thinking about conversations that have taken place between managers and employees, most of the time those conversations are taking place at least a few days after the events that they describe, which means that neither the giver nor the receiver really understand what’s happened.

Dr. Pelè: 13:42
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 13:43
And there’s a forensic reconstruction of events that we think happened but aren’t really clear about their terms and about the details. So already that brings in all new sorts of bias. There’s the recency effect where I’m going to be thinking about things that happened maybe most recently, but maybe are not relevant to the conversation or don’t account for other pieces of that conversation. It brings into the picture other biases like halo effect, where I judge you on the basis of certain things that you’ve done, maybe preconceived notions I have of your work, which can also skew negatively with a negativity bias, thinking about people as their worst selves, not best selves. And And all those biases creep in when we don’t have clarity over what’s actually happened.

Dr. Pelè: 14:33
Mm-hmm.

Joe Hirsch: 14:34
And so the time lapse creates a whole host of problems. But there’s also the emotional baggage that is carried in these conversations when we focus on a past that has happened and not a future that hasn’t happened yet.

Dr. Pelè: 14:50
Mm.

Joe Hirsch: 14:51
And the problem with that is because we start looking people as less of themselves, not more. We take a deficits approach to the conversations, talking about things that we wished had happened, that we wanted to occur, and that haven’t materialized the way we had hoped. Well, that’s a debilitating view of performance, and it leads people to think about themselves quite negatively and futilely.

Dr. Pelè: 15:18
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 15:18
That’s when learned helplessness creeps in. The sense that I can’t do anything to change my circumstances, so why should I even bother trying?

Dr. Pelè: 15:26
Mm-hmm.

Joe Hirsch: 15:27
That’s where fixed mindset comes in. People think of their situations as unchanging because it belongs to a time that is unchanging. So they automatically assume that this is me frozen in time, and that is who I’m going to be, and that is who I am. And that leads to a very debilitating sense of self. So when we focus on a past that people can’t change, and when we think about people as less of themselves and not more, then we frame their performance and their potential as very self-limiting, as tied to a past that they cannot change.

Dr. Pelè: 16:03
Wow. You know, what’s interesting about your work is that I think it stands at the same level of seminal importance as positive psychology or the strengths movement. You know, you know, people may have heard of Martin, Dr. Martin Seligman, who is one of the big guys who brought in the positive psychology movement. But I see you and your work with Marshall Goldsmith as really bringing, bringing in the stuff that makes the strengths movement work. Right. Because, you know, how do you get to talking about strengths if we’re all talking, if we’re talking about the past and all the failures and, How do you focus on people’s strengths? So I wonder if you would, if you wouldn’t mind sharing with us some of your framework. You’ve, you obviously you’ve described some of the science that leads to, to where you are, but how does Semaka Partners engage clients? What frameworks do you use to create results and outcomes for them?

Joe Hirsch: 17:02
We always start with an intake of a greater understanding of what exactly the client’s needs are. And those of course vary group to group, but what appears to be constant in any team, in any organization, is the fear and the concern among management and leadership that these strategies will be too hard to learn and take too much time to adopt. And what we teach people is that though there is a tremendous rigor to the method, It is not something that only a few people can actually learn. It can be scaled. And it’s not something that takes a great amount of time. It is something you will spend a lifetime working towards.

Dr. Pelè: 17:51
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 17:52
Because we’re always trying to get better, but it does not take years and years of practice or to have advanced degrees to perfect. We make the science very real. We take sort of the ivory tower Bring it down to Main Street.

Dr. Pelè: 18:05
Mm-hmm.

Joe Hirsch: 18:06
And one framework that we use is what we call a feedforward interview. And this is something that pairs nicely with existing performance management practices that are already in place, because one of the things we tell clients right off the bat is that we’re not going to ask you to blow up your performance management systems. Because the companies that started doing that when there was an embrace of a more developmental holistic approach to feedback, companies like Adobe or Medtronic or Gap that went all in and went ratingsless eventually pulled back and found a happier medium because they didn’t have the rigor and the metrics by which to measure these changes. So The first thing we believe in is, is measurability and metrics. And that’s why we say let’s use your existing frameworks, but let’s soften the edges of those systems to allow for a more human, two-way conversational approach to occur between manager and employee. So as an example, the feedforward interview is something that occurs really throughout The year. It’s really designed to be used not only at review time, but something that is embedded in the everyday conversations that are taking place at work and about work. And it has 3 parts to it. Mm-hmm. And it follows a journey approach because really performance is a journey. The interview has 3 stages. The first is summit. The second is trek. And the third is climb. Summit, trek, and climb. And the way this conversation unfolds is by taking a look at various stages of performance from a strengths-based approach. So it begins with the summit. So you and I are having a conversation.

Dr. Pelè: 20:05
Mm-hmm.

Joe Hirsch: 20:06
You as my manager might ask me, Joe, tell me about something over the last week, quarter, project, However, however the cadence is set, whether it’s meant to be something happening weekly or not as frequently, tell me about something great that happened for you recently. And immediately, I’m not thinking about something I screwed up on. I’m thinking about something I did very well.

Dr. Pelè: 20:29
Mm-hmm.

Joe Hirsch: 20:30
And I’ll tell you about that moment of peak, that summit of my performance. And that gives you, as my director, as my leader, as my boss, greater insight as to what matters to me. Now, you might think that as my leader, you have a pretty clear picture of what’s been going on and where I’ve done well and where I haven’t. But it’s very surprising for the people who have these conversations just how unaware they were that what mattered to them was not what mattered to someone else.

Dr. Pelè: 21:06
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 21:06
And sometimes these great celebrations that we mark as teams are not nearly as memorable to the individuals who participated in them as these smaller milestones, these smaller moments, you know, these little marks along the way, these pebbles. Yes. Instead of these milestones. Okay. And so not only does it give me a chance to orient the conversation with something that was great, that when I felt alive and, and really accomplished in my work, but also for you to hear what matters to me. And then track, for you as my manager, to guide the conversation in a way that helps me trace the people or conditions that allowed me to experience that moment of success.

Dr. Pelè: 21:48
Mm-hmm.

Joe Hirsch: 21:49
So you’d say, Joe, wow, that, you know, I didn’t realize that, you know, you taking the lead on that project was so important to you and what a difference it made to you. I mean, tell me, but tell me, what, what was it about that experience that made it so memorable? Was it, was it the fact that you got to choose your team? Was it the fact that you were able to sort of direct the course of the project? What was it about that experience that made you feel so alive? And again, sitting back and listening to what that person has to say about that, you know, who and what allowed that success to materialize? Yeah. Because even when we succeed, we rarely do it all by ourselves. And so having an understanding of who and what allowed that to happen makes you more aware of what allowed this to happen and more importantly, to pivot towards replicability, which is the third part, which is the climb. Because doing something once is a moment.

Dr. Pelè: 22:45
Yeah, yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 22:46
Doing it again and again, that’s a habit. And the path to profitability is through scale and through repetition. And just because something good happened once doesn’t mean that there’s a template in place for future success. So the, the climb of this conversation is where you now have identified a moment of peak, a summit, some great success. You’ve traced with the other person the people and conditions that allowed for it to happen. And then you say, okay, Joe, what would it take for this to happen again?

Dr. Pelè: 23:19
Wow.

Joe Hirsch: 23:21
And you listen and you listen and you let the person fill that space With what they think would be the right circumstances, conditions, climate for that to occur. So the feedforward interview is really all about doing more listening and learning and less telling and selling.

Dr. Pelè: 23:45
Wow.

Joe Hirsch: 23:46
And, and when you engage as a listener, you, you begin to learn things that you did not know before. And, and that is where, that’s the big aha for a lot of clients is they, they say, well, well, what is, what, you know, what are the techniques? What are the strategies we need to do? And I say, the first is to just start listening to what other people want to share, but haven’t been given the chance to voice.

Dr. Pelè: 24:13
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 24:13
And, and that’s the first rule because better listening equals better leading. Great leaders are great listeners. And when we make our space smaller, we make other people’s spaces much larger.

Dr. Pelè: 24:28
Wow. You know, all I can tell you is that that was a masterclass right there. You’re very kind. No, seriously, on, you know, you know, a lot of people look at the big issues and they, they don’t make the connection to these very focused smaller micro successes that we have to achieve in order to get those bigger issues. For example, I like to say conversations create culture, right?

Joe Hirsch: 24:54
Totally.

Dr. Pelè: 24:54
I mean, it’s these conversations and being good at them that can lead to a larger success in our cultures. And actually, I was going to ask you a question, but you’ve already answered it. I was going to say, how do you make this stuff stick? Like after people, you know, begin the process or learn these things, how do they actually maintain that. But in the climb, as you’ve described, there is the process of practice and learning and developing through action and repetition. I love all that.

Joe Hirsch: 25:24
And it’s all framed in the context of action. And, and that’s in, in The Feedback Fix. That’s really what I describe. It’s a, it’s a 6-part process. REPAIR is the acronym we use. And that, you know, some of the elements that we just talked about are part of that REPAIR process. Reframing conversations from past to future, that’s R-E, expanding possibilities and creating more agency for people. Being particular, that’s P. Being authentic and being, you know, being very focused on impact, that’s the AI and the R. And then finally, the last one is R, the last R in REPAIR is refining these conversations and these dynamics between team members so that It’s no longer about power, but partnership. And, and that was something we talked about at the outset of our conversation, not just the shift from past to future, but from power to partnership. And this is where we, we really change the mindset with Feedforward, because instead of forcing a change,

Dr. Pelè: 26:29
Mm-hmm.

Joe Hirsch: 26:29
we use our conversations to provoke And

Dr. Pelè: 26:35
insight.

Joe Hirsch: 26:36
And if all you want to do in your feedback conversation is force a change, you probably will be able to do that. You have the power and they don’t. You as the boss and they as the employee, there can only be one view. And, and that’s the view of the person giving you the feedback that will prevail. So power prevails, but it doesn’t last.

Dr. Pelè: 26:55
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 26:56
And that’s the real tragedy of these conversations that you can force a change, but it’s short-lived change.

Dr. Pelè: 27:01
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 27:02
But if you want to create positive lasting impact, then you need to provoke insights and you need for the person who’s on the receiving end of those conversations to own that process. And you only do that through partnership.

Dr. Pelè: 27:17
Yeah. You know, one of the, one of my favorite topics really is the link between some of the technologies, the science, the approaches, the frameworks even that you shared, For what some might even call soft skills, right? Which I don’t know if that’s a very positive spin on what we do because these are powerful skills, right?

Joe Hirsch: 27:38
Yeah.

Dr. Pelè: 27:39
But how do you help people understand the connection between these skills that you’ve been describing and ultimate business profitability? You know, you might run into that CEO that says, listen, I don’t have time to have conversations or, you know, to learn how to listen. You know, like I’m busy, I got to go sell something. How do you help people make the connection between these skills and business profitability, happiness, for example, wellbeing, all the things you’re talking about?

Joe Hirsch: 28:06
Well, if you don’t spend the time now, you will pay later. That is the truth. If you don’t take the time now to invest in, in very actionable, workable solutions for how to hold these conversations, then you will have instead of Clarity and compassion, you will have confusion and conflict in your workplace.

Dr. Pelè: 28:27
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 28:27
Because without clarity, there is no understanding. I don’t know where you stand. You don’t know where I stand. Our business practices become muddled. Our bottom line becomes dragged into a, into a total sea of confusion and incoherence. And unless we are careful and deliberate about these conversations, we’re going to create work cultures that not only feel very toxic, but also are very unprofitable. Because if you don’t have team trust and you don’t have clarity and clear communication, there cannot be any progress. There just cannot.

Dr. Pelè: 29:07
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 29:08
And business opportunities are lost. The the structure and the rhythm of everyday work becomes riddled with confusion and conflict, and there can be no progress. So yes, this may seem at first to be something that is unrelated from business success but is absolutely tied to it, because without a clear plan of how to communicate more clearly and more effectively, then there can be no trust and no coherence internally. And if you can’t get your internal practices straight, how can you present yourself to potential buyers, to potential vendors, to, to clients who very quickly pick up on that lack of confusion and disruption within your own organization. Yeah. And the piece about happiness, I think, comes into this equation more clearly when you think about the fact that when people feel like they’re heard, like they’re seen and that the dynamics of these conversations have shifted from what I’m going to do to you to what I can do for you.

Dr. Pelè: 30:17
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 30:17
Then that creates and restores a greater sense of wholeness and with it happiness because people feel like more of themselves, not less. They feel like their voices are amplified, not silenced, and they feel like they’re part of their own path of progress, not sent to the sideline.

Dr. Pelè: 30:39
Yeah. You know, we’ve talked quite a bit about your book, you know, The Feedback Fix, and we’ve talked about your work as a leader at Semika Partners. But what we haven’t really talked much about is your evangelism. You know, as a keynote speaker, you’re leading the way, I think, in— with this whole message of the strengths-based approach, the feedback, feedforward, dynamic we’ve been discussing. Um, you know, how do people get ahold of you if they want to hear you speak? I know that we have an environment now where traveling may not be, you know, quite a thing, but, but how do people get ahold of you to hear your speaking, maybe to engage your, your company in learning more about your work? How do people contact you online?

Joe Hirsch: 31:20
Best place to find us is at joehirsch.me. Uh, that’s H-I-R-S-C-H.me. And approximately 60% of our business is through the stage, which is now a virtual stage.

Dr. Pelè: 31:36
Yeah.

Joe Hirsch: 31:36
As we’ve moved a lot of our offerings into a virtual space, and we have a number of trainings that allow people to continue to benefit from this without having in-person events. But the rest of the business is really focused on working specifically with your team, which almost always takes— the bulk of which takes place through telework. And so that hasn’t been affected by any of the recent pandemic. And one of the things that I’d love for your listeners to be aware of is that they can continue to get some really great resources out there, really at no cost, through some of the work that we do that’s made available at that website, joehirsch.me. Lots of resources, videos, and trainings. And if they like it, And they’d like to go to the next level where we have a number of different products that we can present them with, different offerings that we have, online courses, actual workshops, virtual workshops. And so these are different ways that we help people engage their employees in a way that creates joy, not fear, that focuses on future that they still can control instead of a past that they can’t change.

Dr. Pelè: 32:46
Wow. Well, Joe, I just want to thank you so much for being a guest with us and for inspiring me. Um, you, as I said, you’re one of the evangelists leading this movement, and I’m just so honored to have learned from you directly. Thank you.

Joe Hirsch: 33:00
Thanks, Dr. Pelè. All the best.

Dr. Pelè: 33:04
Thanks for tuning in to the Profitable Happiness Podcast. For more episodes, visit drpelè.com. And remember, get happy first and success will follow.

Recent Episodes

Subscribe to the Show